Trial field key to GYMNOPOID SPECIES in the Pacific Northwest

Prepared for the Pacific Northwest Key Council

Original key by Helena Kirkwood © 1992

Nomenclatural and Organizational Revision by Buck McAdoo 2003

 

 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

 Overview

 Description of Genera

 Note on Organization of the Key

 Key to Genera

 Key to Collybia, Dendrocollybia, Gymnopus, & Rhodocollybia

 Dendrocollybia

 Beginning of Collybia

 Beginning of Gymnopus

 Beginning of Rhodocollybia

 Bibliography

 Glossary

 Index to Species

OVERVIEW

The 1992 version of Helena Kirkwood’s trial key on Collybia has been altered due to modern name changes. There have been five or six adjustments to the descriptions, one species has been dropped and one added. The organization of the key has been changed due to changes published by Antonín and Noordeloos in A Monograph of Marasmius, Collybia, and Related Genera in Europe in 1997. In general, only three species remain in Collybia, one species has been shifted to Dendrocollybia, while the rest have gone to either Gymnopus or Rhodocollybia, by and large depending on spore deposit color. Specifically, one species formerly in Helena’s Collybia section is now to be found in Rhodocollybia. There is also the genus Megacollybia, a monotypic genus for North America that might possibly be included in the next revision.

 

DESCRIPTION OF GENERA

Collybia – Very small whitish to gray fruiting bodies arising from a sclerotium or from the blackened remains of fungi. Caps usually pallid to canescent. The one exception is Collybia bakerensis which needs to be moved to Gymnopus.

Gymnopus – Medium sized fruiting bodies with caps under 8 cm wide, marcescent, tough to membranous. Caps convex with inrolled margins when young becoming plane with age. Usually glabrous to lubricous. Gills white, often crowded, attached to nearly free. Stems usually tough and pliant, may be hollow or compressed. Veil absent. Spores white to cream, inamyloid, except for Gymnopus fusipes whose spores are rarely reported as pale pinkish. Growth pattern solitary to clustered or cespitose. Habitat on wood, mulch, or humus. Edibility – most are too tough or small to be tempting. Gymnopus acervatus and Gymnopus dryophilus have caused poisonings in certain individuals.

Dendrocollybia – Small gray to gray-brown fruiting bodies with short lateral branches off their stems.

Rhodocollybia – Often larger, putrescent to fleshy fruiting bodies arising from soil or litter. Spores flesh colored to pinkish-yellow, sometimes dextrinoid in Melzer’s, except for R. prolixa var. distorta and R. butyracea form asema which have white to cream colored spores. Fruiting bodies sometimes with rusty spotting and/or radicating stem bases. Stems usually fibrous.

 

A NOTE ON THE ORGANIZATION OF THE KEY

Although an admirer of Helena’s original key, which is precise and well organized, I find I have to form a looser organization due to the vagaries surrounding spore deposit colors in the literature. Rhodocollybia butyracea, for example, enjoys a 50-50 split between those who say the spores are white and those who say it is pinkish. Another example is Gymnopus fusipes, a species that most authors claim has white spores while Pacioni, Lennox, and Moser hold out for pinkish. Antonín and Noordeloos (1997) also include three species in Rhodocollybia that can have white to cream colored spores. The result is that, from the standpoint of spore deposit color alone, the borders between Gymnopus and Rhodocollybia are now blurred. They are blurred even further with the inclusion of Gymnopus fusipes, a species with a fibrous, radicating stem typical of Rhodocollybia, in the genus Gymnopus. The temporary solution is to have double key leads for species with controversial spore colors and blend Gymnopus into Rhodocollybia without an isolated key for the latter genus.

 

 

KEY TO GENERA

1a Spores flesh colored to pinkish, except for Rhodocollybia butyracea f. asema (see 20a) which can have white to buff spores

................................................................................Rhodocollybia

1b Spores white to cream except for the one exception above now to be found in Rhodocollybia

................................................................................2

2a Fruiting bodies with lateral branches off the stems

................................................................................Dendrocollybia

2b Without lateral branches off the stems

................................................................................3

3a Small fruiting bodies arising from a sclerotium or from the blackened remains of fungi. Caps pallid

................................................................................Collybia

3b Medium sized fruiting bodies with caps up to 8 cm wide, caps usually glabrous to lubricous, marcescent and membranous with gills white at first

................................................................................Gymnopus

 

KEY TO COLLYBIA, DENDROCOLLYBIA, GYMNOPUS, & RHODOCOLLYBIA

1a Spore print white to cream

................................................................................2

1b Spore print flesh colored to pinkish

................................................................................21

2a Fruiting bodies with lateral branches off the stems

................................................................................Dendrocollybia racemosa (Pers.: Fr.) R.H. Petersen & Redhead

 CAP 0.3-1.0 cm wide, convex and then plane with a broad umbo, margins inrolled in both mature and immature specimens, color gray-brown, darker at disc. Surface silky, context thin, tough, pliant. GILLS somewhat paler than cap. STEM 3-5 cm long, concolorous with cap. Projections 0.1-0.15 cm in length, arising at right angles to stem over the lower half. The entire stem may be buried in the substrate. It arises from a black, shiny, round sclerotium 0.27 cm in diameter. HABIT gregarious. SPORES 4-5.5 x 2.5-3 microns, ovate, thin-walled, faintly blue in Melzer’s.Dendrocollybia racemosa
Dendrocollybia racemosa
Ben Woo

2b Fruiting bodies without lateral stem branches

................................................................................3

3a Fruiting bodies tiny, with caps no larger than 0.5 cm wide, growing in colonies on much decayed mushrooms, wood, or humus

................................................................................4

3b Fruiting bodies small, but with caps at least 1 cm in width to 5-9 cm in width, solitary to cespitose, on wood, humus, sand or soil

................................................................................6

4a Fruiting bodies arise from sclerotia (seed-like tubers of hyphae)

................................................................................5

4b Fruiting bodies have no sclerotia at their stem bases, but do have prominent white rhizomorphs

................................................................................Collybia cirrhata (Pers.) Quél.

 CAP 0.2-1.0 cm wide, white at margin, warm tan at center, occasionally depressed slightly at maturity, but usually shallowly papillate or broadly umbonate. GILLS white or pallid, subdistant. STEM 1.2-2.5 cm long, concolorous with cap disc or darker, equal. Surface powdery pruinose to tomentose below. SPORES white, 5.5-7.5 x 2.5-3.5 microns, ellipsoid to cylindrical, thin-walled, smooth, inamyloid. Collybia cirrhata
Collybia cirrhata
Michael Beug

5a With orange pumpkin seed-shaped sclerotia

................................................................................Collybia cookei (Bres.) Arnold

 CAP 0.2-0.9 cm wide, uniformly colored white to pale pink or yellow, shallowly papillate when young becoming slightly depressed with age. GILLS white, drying pale pink, subdistant. STEM 0.6-6 cm in length, concolorous with cap at apex, slightly darker at base. Equal. Surface pruinose to pubescent with white, coarse, bristle-like rhizomorphs at base. Often buried for half its length. Emerging from an orange-yellow sclerotium 0.1-0.6 cm in diameter, often flattened and pumpkin seed shaped. HABIT gregarious. SPORES 4.5-5.5 x 2.5-3.5 microns, ovate, thin-walled, smooth, inamyloid. Collybia cookei
Collybia cookei
Michael Beug

5b Brown, apple seed-shaped sclerotia

................................................................................Collybia tuberosa (Bull.:Fr.) P. Kumm.

 CAP 0.2-1.2 cm wide, whitish to buff, sometimes with darker center, convex to plane or centrally depressed. Surface smooth or minutely downy, dry or moist. Margin straight or staying slightly inrolled. Context thin, white. ODOR faintly sweet or fungoid. TASTE none. GILLS adnate to adnexed, subdistant to crowded, white or rarely tinged pinkish. STEM 1-3 cm long and 0.05-1.0 cm thick, equal, white or tinged brown or pinkish, dry, minutely downy, often arising from a small orange-brown to reddish-brown to blackish, appleseed-like sclerotium. SPORES 3-6 x 2-3 microns, elliptic, smooth, inamyloid according to Arora, 5-6.5 x 3-3.5 microns, ovate to cylindric according to Lennox. EDIBILITY unknown. Collybia tuberosa
Collybia tuberosa
Michael Beug

6a (3b) Solitary growth in open, sandy soil

................................................................................Collybia clusilis (Fr.) Sacc.

CAP 0.7-4 cm wide, rusty brown with occasionally 1-2 concentric rings of darker color, fading little when dried. Margins even to somewhat inrolled, or lobed to undulate. Surface dull, faintly powdery. Context thin, tough. ODOR variable. TASTE bitter. GILLS notched, distant, pallid. STEM 1.5-4 cm long and 0.1-0.2 cm thick, concolorous with cap margin, smooth, equal, surface undulate. Scant white tomentum at extreme base. SPORES 7-9.5 x 5-6 microns, broadly ovate and smooth. EDIBILITY unknown. REMARK According to Antonín and Noordeloos the name Collybia clusilis is now in the excluded taxa list. The type from Sweden is lost, leaving some experts to believe this is either a Tephrocybe or a species of Pseudoomphalina.

6b Not fruiting solitary in open, sandy soil

................................................................................7

7a Fruiting bodies grow densely clustered, joined together at bases in tufts of five or more

................................................................................8

7b Fruiting bodies, if clustered, are not joined together at base. May be solitary in other substrates or gregarious

................................................................................11

8a Strong odor and taste of garlic

................................................................................9

8b Faint fungoid odor and taste

................................................................................10

9a Found on logs, stumps, or soil. No reaction with KOH

................................................................................Gymnopus polyphyllus (Peck) Halling

CAP 2.5-4 cm wide, reddish-brown to flesh colored, surface lubricous. Context thin, whitish, pliant. ODOR & TASTE of garlic. GILLS white, very thin, crowded, abruptly and deeply sinuate. STEM reddish-brown beneath a dense, almost velvety whitish to pale gray tomentum. SPORES 5-6 x 3-4 microns, ovate to ellipsoid, smooth, thin-walled, inamyloid. EDIBILITY unknown.

9b Found on wood chips. All parts react with KOH to give a green color

................................................................................Gymnopus dysodes (Halling) Halling

CAP 0.6-6 cm wide, convex with a decurved margin, soon plano-convex to plane, occasionally more or less campanulate with a straight or uplifted margin. Surface glabrous, moist, and somewhat translucent-striate at first, soon conspicuously plicate to sulcate-striate nearly to disc. Color dark reddish-brown when young. Context white, thin over the gills, but 0.5-0.8 cm thick at disc. ODOR pungent of old onions or garlic. TASTE onion-like. GILLS adnate to adnexed, distant, light brown when young, soon fading to a pale pinkish-buff. Edges even. STEM 1.5-4 cm long and 0.2-0.5 cm thick. Equal or somewhat enlarged towards base, round to compressed. Tough when young becoming brittle in age. Concolorous with cap when young fading to a light reddish-brown with age, eventually becoming vinaceous buff. Stuffed becoming hollow in age. Entire surface finely pruinose at first becoming subglabrous at apex in age. SPORES 7.8-8.4 x 3.5-4.2 microns, ovoid to lacrymoid, smooth, inamyloid. HABIT and HABITAT found gregarious and cespitose on wood chips. EDIBILITY unknown.

10a (8b) Smooth red-brown stem with tomentum at base

................................................................................Gymnopus acervatus (Fr.) Murrill

 CAP 1.3-5 cm wide, reddish-brown at disc becoming paler at margin. Hygrophanous, fading to pale flesh color. Firm, pliable, context thin, colored as cap surface. GILLS adnexed to sinuate to nearly free, close, narrow. White to buff to pinkish. STEM very long, 5-11 cm long , thin, reddish-brown with rather thick white tomentum at the base extending up to one half the length of the stem. SPORES 5-6 x 2.5-3.5 microns, ovate to broadly ellipsoid, smooth, thin-walled, inamyloid. HABIT and HABITAT often found in huge clusters on much decayed wood with frequently buried stems arising from the crevice of a log or from a hole in the ground. EDIBILITY poisonous to some individuals.Gymnopus acervatus
Gymnopus acervatus
John Davis

10b Bicolored stem without tomentum

................................................................................Gymnopus erythropus (Pers.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel. et al.

CAP brown when fresh, hygrophanous, fading rapidly to pale brownish-buff. Convex to plane with uplifted margins in age. 0.4-5.5 cm wide, moist becoming dry and opaque. Densely white pubescent overall on young specimens, sometimes balding at margin. Smooth, pliant, margins inrolled at first, then plane to decurved. Context nearly white, 0.1-0.3 cm thick. ODOR & TASTE mild. GILLS adnexed, close to subdistant. Pallid to pale cream with age. Edges erode with age. 2-3 tiers of lamellulae. STEM 1.5-5 cm long and 0.1-0.8 cm thick, equal or slightly enlarged downwards, rounded to compressed. Bicolorous, upper fourth pallid and dark brown below. Brittle, smooth, shiny. Stuffed becoming hollow in age. SPORES 6-8.5 x 3.5-4 microns. Ovoid to ellipsoid, inamyloid, slightly greenish in alkali. HABIT and HABITAT scattered to cespitose on decaying hardwoods. EDIBILITY unknown. REMARK Surface cells on the stem contain a granular pigment that turns green but does not dissolve in KOH. (Can only be seen with a microscope).

 

11a (7b) Caps white, gray, cream, or pinkish-buff

................................................................................12

11b Caps brown, purple-brown, ochre, pale cinnamon, or tawny-brown

................................................................................14

12a Cap context very thin, 0.1-0.2 cm thick, and stem not enlarged at base

................................................................................Gymnopus confluens (Pers.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel., et al.

 CAP 2-5 cm wide, dark grayish-flesh colored, drying much lighter. Surface smooth, dull even when moist. Context tough and pliant. ODOR & TASTE mild. GILLS concolorous, almost free, thin, and very crowded. STEM 4-9 cm long and 0.2-0.5 cm thick, dark reddish-brown at base and generally appearing reddish under a dense white tomentum. Hollow, frequently compressed, tough and pliant (like Marasmius). SPORES 7-9.2 x 3.5-4.2 microns, elliptic, smooth, inamyloid. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious in small tufts in partial rings in mixed woods. EDIBILITY inedible. REMARK common. Gymnopus confluens
Gymnopus confluens
Ben Woo

12b Cap context greater than 0.3 cm at disc

................................................................................13

13a Stems 0.3-0.5 cm thick, enlarged at base

................................................................................Collybia bakerensis A.H.Sm.

CAP 1.8-3.7 cm wide, broadly convex becoming plane, sometimes with broad umbo, white to cream colored, often flushed with pink, darkening to yellow with age. Smooth, moist, with a faint yellow staining reaction on handling. Margin downcurved to uplifted at maturity. Context firm, white. ODOR aromatic, sweet and pleasant. TASTE mild. GILLS concolorous with cap, staining faintly yellow. Thin, close. STEM short, 1-3 cm long and 0.3-0.5 cm thick, somewhat bulbous at base, slightly darker than cap. SPORES 6.5-8.5 x 3.5-4.5 microns, ovate, smooth, thin-walled, inamyloid. HABIT and HABITAT scattered on fallen logs in moist areas, often inside of bark. REMARK This species might be transferred to Gymnopus, but could end up elsewhere. Compare with Rhodocollybia maculata var. fulva.

13b Stems 0.5-1.2 cm thick, tapering at base

................................................................................Rhodocollybia maculata var. maculata (see 26a)

(This Rhodocollybia is double keyed here because Kauffman, Rea, Wakefield & Dennis all claim the spores are white. Moser, McKnight, Antonín & Noordeloos claim they can be ‘cream to pinkish’.)

14a (11b) Caps peppery to acrid in taste

................................................................................Gymnopus peronatus (Bolt.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel., et al.

 CAP 2.5-6 cm wide, convex to plane, often with broad umbo and irregularly lobed margins. Smooth to innately fibrillose, sometimes grooved above gills. Ochre-cinnamon to pinkish-brown with paler margin. Hygrophanous. Context white to pale yellow. ODOR mild. TASTE peppery to acrid. GILLS almost free, distant, sometimes forked near stem. Ochre to yellowish or pinkish-brown, sometimes with lilac tints. Edges entire or finely whitish granulose fringed. STEM 3-7.5 cm long and 0.3-0.8 cm thick. Smooth or floccose at apex becoming fibrillose-striate below, usually expanded towards base. Ochre-brown to yellowish, often more orange-brown towards the base which is covered with buff to yellowish hairs. SPORES 8.5-10 x 3-4 microns, smooth, elliptic to subcylindrical. HABIT and HABITAT usually found in dense groups in forest litter, on conifer and hardwood debris. EDIBILITY considered too acrid to eat. However, a restaurant near Bellingham dries them, re-constitutes them, and serves them up!Gymnopus peronatus
Gymnopus peronatus
Ben Woo

14b Taste not peppery or acrid

................................................................................15

15a Stems longitudinally grooved

................................................................................16

15b Stems smooth

................................................................................17

16a Stems dark brown, velvety to unpolished

................................................................................Gymnopus striatipes (Peck) Halling

CAP 3-7 cm wide, convex with incurved margin when young becoming broadly convex to nearly plane with straight to uplifted margin in age; surface smooth and moist; pale brown to cinnamon-buff, paler when dried. Context thin and pliant. ODOR & TASTE mild. GILLS pallid, subdistant, occasionally marked with rusty spots. STEM 5-7 cm long and 0.3-0.7 cm thick at apex. Dark brown when moist, concolorous with cap when drying. Hollow, compressed, distinctly longitudinally grooved. Base with white rhizomorphs. SPORES 5-6 x 2.5-3.5 microns, narrowly ellipsoid, smooth, thin-walled. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious to scattered under alder. EDIBILITY unknown.

16b Stems fusiform, pallid becoming red-brown towards base

................................................................................Gymnopus fusipes (Bull.: Fr.) S.F.Gray

CAP 3-8 cm wide, broadly conical becoming convex to plane with low umbo. Dark red-brown to rusty-brown fading to cinnamon-flesh color when drying. Smooth to slightly rugulose, margins translucent striate when moist. Surface shiny, often with rusty to yellowish spots. ODOR mild, sometimes sweetish. TASTE mildly fungoid. GILLS adnate to emarginate, subdistant, edges entire. Pale gray-brown to tan becoming dark brown to red-brown in age, often with rusty spots. STEM 1-2 cm thick and 5-11 cm long, fusiform and longitudinally sulcate, often curved or twisted, fibrillose or glabrous. Pallid at apex becoming dark reddish-brown below. Base tapered and originating from a root-like black sclerotium. SPORES 5.4-6.6 x 3.2-3.8 microns, ellipsoid to amygdaliform. HABIT and HABITAT solitary or in compact clusters around roots and stumps of oak, beech, birch, or chestnut. EDIBILITY mediocre, can cause stomach upset. REMARK Widespread in Europe, rare here. Pacioni and Lennox believe the spore deposit is pinkish. Moser describes them as ‘cream to pinkish’.

17a (15b) Gills brown to nearly black. A green color reaction to KOH

................................................................................Gymnopus alkalivirens (Singer) Halling

CAP 0.8-2.7 cm wide, convex with the margin inrolled at first, then expanding to obtusely conic to broadly convex to plane, and finally plane with a low, broad umbo. Margin obscurely rugose-striate or nearly sulcate. Surface dull, glabrous, hygrophanous, dark pinkish-brown when moist, fading either at the disc only or at the margin first to a cinnamon-buff with a rufous cast. Fully dried caps can be buff or brown to black. Context thin to very thin at cap margin, whitish with a rufous flush. ODOR & TASTE mild. GILLS narrowly adnate to nearly free, close, narrow with edges entire, straight to slightly undulate; brown becoming black to chocolate brown when dried. STEM 3-8 cm long and 0.1-0.3 cm thick, equal or slightly enlarged at base, hollow. Dark pinkish-brown to black, somewhat paler at apex. SPORES 5.4-6.5 x 2.2-3.2 microns, lacrymoid, narrowly ellipsoid in profile. White in deposit, slightly wrinkled in water mounts, but smooth and pale greenish in KOH. All parts turn green in KOH and NH4OH. HABIT and HABITAT solitary to scattered to even cespitose on soil, moss, leaf litter, old fern hummocks, or decaying woody debris. EDIBILITY unknown. REMARK According to Halling, west coast Gymnopus alkalivirens is most likely Gymnopus fuscopurpureus, a distinct species. Arora describes G. fuscopurpureus under the former genus Collybia, but claims there are numerous variants in the group. Very possibly both species occur out here.

17b Gills white, buff, pale yellow, or ochre to ochre-brown or red-brown

................................................................................18

18a Stem base obviously strigose

................................................................................Gymnopus peronatus (mild tasting form)

The mild tasting form of G. peronatus (14a) is indistinguishable from the acrid form macroscopically. In our area it seems to be rarer than the acrid tasting form, but how many of us have volunteered for this taste test in the first place?

18b Base of stem bald or with rhizomorphs

................................................................................19

19a Gill edges entire or subentire

................................................................................Gymnopus dryophilus (Bull.: Fr.) Murrill

CAP 1-6 cm wide, convex to plane, sometimes with umbo, sometimes with depressed discs. Surface smooth, slightly viscid when moist. Orange-brown to ochre-brown fading hygrophanously to pale ochre or ochre-pink at margins first. Margins striate halfway to disc when moist, undulate in age. Context thin, white, rather pliant. ODOR & TASTE mild. GILLS sinuate to adnate, crowded, thin, white to buff, sometimes yellowing in age. STEM 3.5-7 cm long and 0.2-0.6 cm thick. Glabrous with inlay of finely twisted fibrils. Yellow-ochre becoming paler at apex, sometimes darkening to ochre-brown towards base. Equal or slightly expanded towards base. Abundant white rhizomorphs at base. SPORES 5.6-6.4 x 2.8-3.5 microns, lacrymoid to ovoid, smooth. HABIT and HABITAT scattered to gregarious on humus, wood chip mulch, or well rotted wood. EDIBILITY use caution, has caused poisoning to some individuals.

19b Gill edges crenulate to serrulate

................................................................................20

20a Caps pale brown, brown, gray-brown or tan with darker disc

................................................................................R. butyracea forma asema (Fr.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel., et al.

 CAP 2.5-6 cm wide, convex to plane, usually with low umbo and uplifted margins in age. Smooth, shiny, brown to gray-brown fading to tan when drying with a whitish margin. Context whitish, thin. ODOR mildly resinous, pleasant. TASTE mild. GILLS adnexed to notched, white, thin, very crowded. Edges crenulate. STEM 4-8 cm long and 0.4-1.5 cm thick. Glabrous to finely longitudinally fibrillose, more rarely longitudinally grooved. Gray-brown to brown, usually expanding at base. Hollow, corticate, base with white tomentum. SPORES 5.7-7.2 x 2.8-3.8 microns, elliptic, smooth, whitish-cream in deposit. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious in mixed woods on conifer duff and leaf litter. EDIBILITY Caution is advised. This form has been aligned with Gymnopus dryophilus before, a species that has affected some individuals adversely. REMARK Breitenbach & Kränzlin, Michael, Hennig, & Kreisel, Hvass, Jordan, and Kubicka all write that form asema has white spores. R butyracea forma asema
R butyracea forma asema
Michael Beug

20b Caps red-brown to dark ochre-brown

................................................................................R. butyracea var. butyracea (Bull.: Fr.) Lennox

 CAP 3-7 cm wide, convex to broadly umbonate, dark reddish-brown when young to dull red-brown or dark ochre-brown with an olive tinge in age. Surface smooth with a fatty luster when moist. Context white. ODOR mild to mildly fruity. TASTE mild, rarely raphanoid. GILLS sinuate, finely serrate at first, then strongly eroded. White becoming yellowish on drying. No rusty spotting. STEM 5-9 cm long and 0.4-0.8 cm thick. Pinkish-brown to yellow-brown becoming more reddish-brown towards apex in age. Longitudinally striate-fibrillose. Base clavate, white-matted tomentose, often with pseudorhiza. SPORES 6.5-9 x 3-4.5 microns, narrowly ellipsoid to ovate, smooth with a dextrinoid endosporium. HABIT and HABITAT scattered to loosely cespitose in thick duff in conifer forests. EDIBILITY edible. REMARK Smith claims spores are yellowish in deposit. Lennox has them as cream to pale orange. Rea, Dahncke, Svrcek, Kubicka, Cetto, and Grunert all list the spores as white. Moser solves the problem by writing ‘spores cream to pinkish’. One wonders whether the spores could be white at first and become pinkish as the carpophore matures or whether differences in substrate affect spore color.R butyracea var butyracea
R butyracea var butyracea
Kit Scates Barnhart

21a (1b) Stems radicating, i.e. have pseudorhiza

................................................................................22

21b Stems not radicating

................................................................................31

22a Rust colored spots on some part of fruiting body

................................................................................23

22b No rust colored spots

................................................................................29

23a Gills yellow

................................................................................R. maculata var. scorzonerea (Fr.) Lennox

CAP 3.5-12 cm wide, plane at maturity and frequently straight or slightly recurved, either depressed or umbonate. Surface smooth, color pale buff to yellowish, darkening somewhat with age. Scattered watery spots and rust stains. Context thick, pale buff to yellowish. ODOR faint and somewhat fragrant. TASTE bitter. GILLS adnate to emarginate, yellowish, narrow, thin, and crowded. Sometimes rusty spotted. STEM 3.5-17 cm long and 0.6-4.0cm thick. Pallid at the apex, darkening slightly below, or becoming the color of the cap or more yellow with age. Rusty stains especially at the base. Markedly longitudinally sulcate-striate at maturity, subradicate. SPORES 7-8.5 x 4.5-5 microns, ovate to ellipsoid, smooth, dextrinoid. HABIT and HABITAT scattered on decayed coniferous wood. EDIBILITY inedible.

23b Gills white, pale orange, pale gray-brown to red-brown

................................................................................24

24a Distinctive odor of almonds

................................................................................Rhodocollybia oregonensis (A.H. Sm.) Lennox

 CAP 4-10.5 cm wide (usually at least 7 cm), very broadly convex becoming plane, dark vinaceous brown, fading towards margin, colors becoming uneven and spotty with age. Margins never truly straight. Subviscid when moist. Context thin, white or reddish-stained. ODOR strong of almonds. TASTE faint and unpleasant. GILLS sinuate, crowded, edges serrated when young, later frayed and eroded. White to pale orange becoming yellowish when drying. Frequently stained with rusty brown spots. STEM 6.5-20 cm long and 0.5-3.0 cm thick, white but stained with rusty brown especially near the base. Fibrous and tending to split longitudinally. Buried for about half its length and covered there with pieces of rotten wood. Without rhizomorphs. SPORES 6-8 x 3.5-4 microns, ovate, hyaline, smooth. Wall thickness variable, endosporium dextrinoid. HABIT and HABITAT on rotten conifer logs and debris. EDIBILITY inedible.Rhodocollybia oregonensis
Rhodocollybia oregonensis
Michael Beug

24b No distinctive odor

................................................................................25

25a Bitter taste

................................................................................26

25b No bitter taste

................................................................................27

26a Caps white to pale buff

................................................................................R. maculata var. maculata (Alb.& Schw.: Fr.) Singer

 CAP 4-9 cm wide, convex to nearly plane in age, surface smooth, felt-like. White to pale buff, often with dingy reddish stains. Context white, firm. ODOR mild. TASTE bitter. GILLS notched, thin, crowded. Edges serrated to eroded. White to pale pinkish-buff, soon with reddish stains. STEM 4-20 cm long and 0.5-1.2 cm thick. White developing rusty stains towards base. Equal, tough, fibrous, hollow, tapering abruptly at substrate. Base with dense white mycelium. SPORES 5-7 x 4.5-6 microns, subglobose with a prominent apiculus and a shallow suprahilar depression. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious in litter, humus, and conifer duff in mixed woods. EDIBILITY inedible.R maculata var maculata
R maculata var maculata
Bryce Kendrick

26b Caps vinaceous brown to dark chestnut

................................................................................Rhodocollybia badiialba (Murrill) Lennox

CAP 2.4-11 cm wide (usually 5-7 cm wide), convex to plane with a broad, shallow umbo. Vinaceous brown to nearly black drying somewhat lighter. Margins frequently fraying with age, sometimes revolute. Surface smooth and slippery but not viscid. Matte on drying. Context white, soft. ODOR faint to pungent. TASTE slowly becoming unpleasant and bitter. GILLS sinuate and crowded, white becoming yellowish when drying. Edges serrated when young becoming eroded in age. STEM 5-11 cm long and 0.5-0.9 cm thick. Fibrous, flesh colored at apex darkening downwards to vinaceous tan, staining reddish-brown. Abundant white rhizomorphs at base. SPORES 3.5-5.5 x 3-4.5 microns, globose, smooth, hyaline with a dextrinoid endosporium. Walls variable in thickness. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious to loosely cespitose on much decayed logs or thick duff in dense conifer woods. EDIBILITY inedible. REMARK Closely related to Rhodocollybia extuberans but does not react to PDAB and is bitter to taste.

27a (25b) Caps white tinged with pink

................................................................................Rhodocollybia maculata var. occidentalis (A.H. Sm.) Lennox

CAP 2.6-11 cm wide, convex to nearly plane at maturity, sometimes shallowly undulate. Whitish tinged with pale pinkish-buff, but darkening with age, especially at disc. Rusty red spots usually present. Surface moist, dull, and faintly powdery. Context concolorous, thick over disc and tapering abruptly at margin. Sometimes frayed at margin. ODOR faint, pleasant. TASTE bitter. GILLS sinuate to emarginate, rather waxy, thin, crowded, whitish to pale orange. Edges even at first, eroded with age. STEM 4.3-15 cm long and 0.8-2.1 cm thick. Whitish staining rusty red in lower half. Often compressed and sulcate-striate to shallowly furrowed at maturity. Surface faintly powdery at first. Solid becoming hollow in upper half in age. Base tapering abruptly into short pseudorhiza. SPORES 6.5-11 x 4-6 microns, narrowly ovate to ellipsoid, thin-walled, dextrinoid. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious to cespitose in thick duff or on much decayed coniferous wood. EDIBILITY unknown.

27b Caps vinaceous brown, rusty brown, red-brown to cinnamon-flesh color

................................................................................28

28a Caps dark red-brown fading to cinnamon-flesh

................................................................................Gymnopus fusipes (see 15b)

(This species is keyed out here because a few authors contend the spores are pinkish.)

28b Caps brown to vinaceous brown with rusty brown margins

................................................................................Rhodocollybia extuberans (Fr.) Lennox sensu Lennox

CAP 2-5.5 cm wide, conical-campanulate becoming plane with a low or prominent umbo. Dark vinaceous brown shading to rusty-brown towards the margin, and fading overall on drying. Surface slippery to lubricous when moist, drying smooth and dull. Context reddish-brown, firm, tough. ODOR faint, sweet. TASTE mild. GILLS sinuate, white to very pale yellow becoming yellower upon drying. Often spotted dark brown. Edges finely serrate when immature becoming eroded in age. STEM 3.5-8 cm long and 0.3-2.0 cm thick, concolorous with cap margin sometimes becoming flesh colored at apex and darkening towards base. Fibrous, grooved, and twisted striate tending to split longitudinally. Powdery at apex and matted tomentose below substrate at base. With short pseudorhiza and with or without rhizomorphs. SPORES 7-10 x 3-4.5 microns, ovate with dextrinoid endosporium. Wall thickness variable. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious to cespitose on well decayed conifer wood. EDIBILITY unknown. REMARK Closely related to Rhodocollybia badiialba, but reacts with PDAB to produce a bright magenta color in the solution. Also worthy of note is that, according to Halling, some western collections of Rhodocollybia unakensis (Murrill) Halling have been called Rhodocollybia extuberans before. Meanwhile, Collybia extuberans (Fr.) Quél. in Europe has become a synonym of Gymnopus ocior (Pers.) Antonín & Noordel., a completely different species.

29a (22b) Gills yellow to light orange

................................................................................Rhodocollybia maculata var. nigra Lennox

CAP 2.7-4 cm wide, convex to plane, dark brownish-black, shiny, unchanging when drying. Context context quite thick, firm, white to faintly yellowish. ODOR sweet. TASTE pleasant at first, becoming bitter. GILLS emarginate, rather thick, shallow, subdistant. Cream colored to peach, unchanging, not staining. Edges even. STEM 7-7.5 cm long and 1.2-1.4 cm thick. White near apex becoming yellow below. No rusty staining. Thickest at base and tapering above and below this point. Striate grooved in age, at least near base. Buried for half its length in much decayed wood. SPORES 7-8 x 4.5-5 microns, ellipsoid, dextrinoid. HABIT and HABITAT cespitose on much decayed wood. EDIBILITY inedible.

29b Gills white or pinkish tinted

................................................................................30

30a Distinctive odor of moldy cinnamon or Vick’s Vaporub

................................................................................Rhodocollybia subnigra Lennox

CAP 4.5-6 cm wide, convex to nearly plane with a shallow umbo, margins even and almost straight. Dark reddish-brown and subhygrophanous, drying lighter. Surface lubricous when wet, later dry, matte to almost fibrillose. Context rather thick and soft, pinkish-cream. ODOR strong like Vick’s Vaporub or moldy cinnamon. TASTE mild. GILLS narrowly adnexed and deeply sinuate, thin, close, edges even becoming eroded in age. White, unchanging and non-staining. STEM 8-10 cm long and 0.9-2.0 cm thick. Light orange becoming pallid below substrate. Striate-grooved, non-staining, stuffed, fibrous, tending to split longitudinally. More or less fusiform, tapering abruptly towards base. Buried for about half its length. No rhizomorphs at base. SPORES 6.5-7.5 x 3-4 microns, narrowly ovate to ellipsoid, thin-walled, dextrinoid, smooth. HABITAT no data, reported from King County, Wash. EDIBILITY unknown.

30b Odor faintly to heavily aromatic

................................................................................Rhodocollybia subsulcatipes (A.H. Sm.) Lennox

CAP 5-8 cm wide, convex to plane with inrolled margin at first, then margin uplifting and tending to split in age. Deep vinaceous-brown to rusty vinaceous fading hygrophanously to pale vinaceous. Surface polished and margins translucent striate when moist, opaque when faded. Context thin, firm, concolorous with cap surface. ODOR aromatic, somewhat like benzaldehyde. TASTE mild. GILLS nearly free, subdistant, slightly ventricose. Pale grayish-vinaceous becoming dull vinaceous in age. STEM 6-10 cm long and 1.0-1.6 cm thick, concolorous with cap at apex but darker at base. Solid, surface smooth or longitudinally grooved. Tapering at base to a long pseudorhiza. SPORES 5-5.5 x 4.5-5 microns, globose, hyaline, smooth, inamyloid. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious on humus. EDIBILITY unknown. REMARK Rare. The only reported collection is from Storm King Mountain in the Olympic National Park.

31a (21b) With prominent umbo

................................................................................32

31b Without umbo

................................................................................Rhodocollybia maculata var. immutabilis (A.H. Sm.) Lennox

CAP 2.5-3.2 cm wide, convex expanding to nearly plane at maturity, margins straight and even. Pale grayish-cream with no color change on drying. Surface slightly powdery at first. Context thin. ODOR faint, sweet. TASTE mild. GILLS broadly adnate, thick, subdistant. Concolorous with cap, not staining. Edges even, not eroding in age. STEM 3.5-5 cm long and 0.5-1.0 cm thick. Concolorous with cap or somewhat darker, hollow, tapering towards apex. Surface streaked striate. Some white appressed tomentum at base. SPORES 6.5-8 x 4-4.5 microns, ovate to ellipsoid, dextrinoid, thin-walled, smooth. HABIT and HABITAT gregarious on conifer duff. EDIBILITY unknown. REMARK According to Antonín & Noordel. the var. immutabilis should now be considered conspecific with Rhodocollybia maculata var. maculata.

32a Gill edges serrate

................................................................................33

32b Gill edges entire

................................................................................Rhodocollybia maculata var. fulva Lennox

CAP 1.7-2.7 cm wide, conical to broadly conical expanding to convex, sharply umbonate with margins remaining slightly inrolled and even. Dark vinaceous red, drying lighter. Surface moist, smooth. Context thick at the disc and tapering rapidly at the margins, brittle, firm, flesh color. ODOR & TASTE mild. GILLS narrowly adnexed to sinuate, thin, crowded, narrow. White with conspicuous rusty-red spots. Edges even. STEM 3.5-6.5 cm long and 0.3-0.5 cm thick. Solid, equal, pallid to flesh colored, staining rusty-red. Striate-grooved at maturity, base non-radicating with yellow and white rhizomorphs. SPORES 5.5-6.5 x 3.5-4 microns, ovate, smooth, thin-walled, dextrinoid. HABIT and HABITAT cespitose on wood. EDIBILITY unknown.

33a Caps tan, brown, gray-brown usually with darker disc

................................................................................Rhodocollybia butyracea form asema (see 20a)

The form asema is an interesting case. Breitenbach & Kränzlin (1991) show a photo (pg. 172) of a specimen with a glabrous stem and white to cream spores. However, they also write that Collybia butyracea var. asema can have a stem that is longitudinally grooved. It is this grooved stemmed version that has been collected at Deception Pass Park in Washington, and it has pale pinkish spores. It also has a pale brick colored stem that contrasts with the tan to pale brown cap. A photo of the grooved stemmed version can be seen in Moser and Jülich’s Farbatlas der Basidiomyceten (1985), Collybia photo #11. This complex needs further review.

33b Caps red-brown, rusty-brown, dark ochre, sometimes with olive tinge

................................................................................Rhodocollybia butyracea (see 20b)

 

NOMENCLATURAL BIBLIOGRAPHY

 

  1. Antonín, V. & M. Noordeloos. 1997. A Monograph of Marasmius, Collybia, and Related Genera in Europe in Libri Botanici, Vol.17, (12, 15, 27-28, 32, 57, 84, 88-89, 102, 117, 120-121, 125, 134, 137, 186.)
  2. Arora, David. 1986. Mushrooms Demystified. Second Edition. Ten Speed Press, Berkeley.
  3. Breitenbach, J. & F. Kränzlin. 1991. Fungi of Switzerland, Vol.3. Edition Mykol- ogia, Lucerne, Switzerland. (172).
  4. Cetto, B., 1987. Enzyklopadie der Pilze, Band 2. Arti Grafiche Saturnia, Trento,
  5. Italy. (427).

  6. Dahncke, R., 1993. 1200 Pilze in Farbfotos. AT Verlag Aarau, Stuttgart. (325).
  7. Grunert, H. & R. 1984. Steinbachs Naturfuhrer – Pilze. Mosaik Verlag, Munich. (94).
  8. Halling, R. 2001. A Revision of Collybia s.l. in the Northeastern United States and Adjacent Canada. (Rhodocollybia section, pgs. 5, 7.)
  9. Hughes, Karen W., Ronald H. Petersen, James E. Johnson, Jean-Marc Montcalvo, Rytas Vilgalys, Scott A. Redhead, Tiffany Thomas and Laura L. McGhee. 2001. Infragenic Phylogeny of Collybia s.str. based on Sequences of Ribosomol ITS and LSU Regions. Mycological Research 105(2): 169.
  10. Kauffman, C. 1918. The Agaricaceae of Michigan. Michigan Biological Survey, Lansing, Michigan. (768).
  11. Kubicka, J. 1979. Champignons d'Europe. Artia, Prague. (144).
  12. Lennox, J. 1979. Collybioid Genera in the Pacific Northwest. Mycotaxon 9: 131-229.
  13. Pacioni, Giovanni, translated by Simon Pleasance, edited by Gary Lincoff. 1981. Simon and Shuster’s Guide to Mushrooms. Simon & Shuster, New York.
  14. McKnight, K. & V. 1987. Peterson Field Guides – Mushrooms. Houghton Mifflin Co., Boston. (150).
  15. Michael, Hennig, & Kreisel, 1987. Handbuch fur Pilzfreunde, Vol.3. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart. (314).
  16. Moser, M. 1983. Keys to Agarics and Boleti. Roger Phillips, London. (154-155).
  17. Moser, M. & W. Jülich, W. 1985. Farbatlas der Basidiomyceten. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart and New York.
  18. Pacioni, G. 1981. Simon & Schuster’s Guide to Mushrooms. Simon & Schuster, N.Y. (44).
  19. Rea, C., 1922. British Basidiomycetaceae. Cambridge University Press. (330-331).
  20. Smith, A.H., 1979. How to Know the Gilled Mushrooms. William C. Brown Co., Dubuque, Iowa. (90-92).
  21. Smith, A.H. & N. Weber, 1958. The Mushroom Hunter’s Field Guide. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor. (141).
  22. Svrcek, M., 1983. The Hamlyn Book of Mushrooms and Fungi. Artia, Prague. (172).
  23. Wakefield, E. & R.W.G. Dennis. 1981. Common British Fungi. Saiga Publishing Co., Surrey, England. (140).
  24. Williams, J., 1975. The Collybioid Fungi of Western Washington. Doctorate.

 

GLOSSARY

 

acrid – sharp tasting, worse than peppery.

amygdaliform – almond-shaped.

benzaldehyde – aroma of peach kernels.

campanulate – bell-shaped.

canescent – becoming densely covered with whitish or grayish down or becoming gray or hoary.

carpophore – the whole fruiting body, sometimes means the stem of the fruiting body.

cespitose – growing in tufts or close clusters from a common base.

clavate – thick towards the base, club-like.

compressed – of a stem, elliptical to flattened in cross section.

context – flesh of cap or stem (excluding the surface layer).

corticate – possessing a rind-like outer layer.

crenulate – finely scalloped.

decurved – when referring to a cap margin or scales means curved downward.

dextrinoid – staining yellowish-brown or reddish-brown in Melzer’s reagent.

emarginate – a kind of gill attachment where the gills are abruptly adnexed or sinuate with a notch near the stem.

endosporium – the innermost layer of the spore wall.

equal – of a stem, the same diameter throughout its length, cylindric.

even – of cap margin, means not wavy or lobed; of gill edges, means not toothed, eroded, fringed, etc.; of cap surface, stem, or spores, means without striations, elevations or depressions.

fibrillose – composed of delicate fibers which are long and evenly arranged on the surface.

fibrous – composed of tough, string-like tissue.

floccose – loose, cottony tufts on stem or cap.

frondose – pertaining to broad-leafed trees.

fusiform – spindle-shaped, narrowing from a thicker middle at both ends.

glabrous – bald, without hairs or raised fibrils, scales, warts, or patches.

granulose – covered with a granule-like substance.

gymnopusoid – resembling in general form a mushroom of the genus Gymnopus in its historical wide sense that includes the genera Collybia, Gymnopus, and Rhodocollybia.

hyaline – colorless.

hygrophanous – cap surface changing color markedly as it dries, usually having a water soaked appearance when wet and turning a lighter, opaque color when drying.

inamyloid – remaining clear or becoming yellow in Melzer’s reagent, not amyloid or dextrinoid, same as non-amyloid.

KOH – potassium hydroxide, an agent commonly used to revive dried mushroom mater- ial or show chemical reactions on the surface of the mushroom and microscopic features.

lacrymoid – tear-shaped.

lamellulae – shorter gills that do not span the entire distance from cap margin to stem.

lobed - having rather large, rounded divisions of the cap margin.

lubricous – greasy, slippery, or oily, but not viscid (sticky) or slimy.

marcescent – able to revive when moistened after having been dried.

membranous – like a membrane, skin-like or somewhat like Kleenex.

mycelium – a mass of hyphae or fungus filaments at the base of a stem.

nomen dubium – dubious name, one of uncertain sense.

papillate – with sharp, nipple-like protuberance on the cap surface.

PDAB – a solution of p-diaminobenzaldehyde in 70% ethanol.

plicate – pleated, folded like a fan.

pruinose – looking finely powdered or finely granular.

pseudorhiza – a long, root-like extension of the lower stem.

pubescent – covered with short, soft, downy hairs.

radicating – forming a root.

raphanoid – odor of radishes.

recurved – curved back; when pertaining to cap margin or scales, means curved back upwards.

revolute – pertaining to cap margin, rolled back or upwards.

rhizomorphs – cord-like strands of twisted hyphae present around stem base.

rugose – coarsely wrinkled.

rugulose – finely wrinkled.

sclerotium – a knot of firm, frequently rounded mass of hyphae, usually underground and giving rise to a fruiting body or a mycelium.

serrate – saw-toothed to almost ragged.

serrulate – minutely serrate.

strigose – long, coarse, thickish hairs usually found on a stem.

sub- - a prefix denoting ‘nearly, more or less, somewhat like, etc.’

substrate – the material that a fungus is growing on

sulcate – grooved.

taxon (plural is ‘taxa’) – a named form, variety, species, etc.

tomentose – covered with soft hairs, often soft, densely matted hairs like a woolen blanket.

tomentum – a covering of densely matted woolly hairs.

umbilicate – refers to a cap a narrow, moderate, or deep depression in the center which may or may not have a small umbo in the bottom.

umbo – a raised knob or mound at the center of the cap.

umbonate – a cap with an umbo.

undulate – wavy, usually referring to a cap margin.

vinaceous – the color of wine-stained cloth.

 

INDEX TO THE SPECIES

 GENUS AND SPECIES KEY ENTRIES
   
 COLLYBIA (Fr.) Staude  
    C. bakerensis A.H. Sm. 13a
    C. cirrhata (Pers.) Quél. 4b, 5b
       = Microcollybia cirrhata (Pers.: Pers.) Lennox  
       = Collybia amanitae (Batsch) Kreisel  
    C. clusilis (Fr.) Sacc. 6a
    C. cookei (Bres.) Arnold 5a, 5b
       = Microcollybia cookei (Bres.) Lennox  
       = Collybia cirrhata var. cookei Bres.  
       = Collybia tuberosa var. cookei (Bres.) Bon & Courtecuisse  
    C. extuberans (Fr.) Quél. 28b
    Collybia tuberosa (Bull.: Fr.) P. Kumm. 5b
       = Microcollybia tuberosa (Bull.: Fr.) Lennox  
       = Marasmius sclerotipes Bres.  
       = Collybia picetorum Velen.  
 DENDROCOLLYBIA R.H. Petersen & Redhead  
    D. racemosa (Pers.: Fr.) R.H. Petersen & Redhead 2a
       = Collybia racemosa (Pers.: Fr.) Quél.  
       = Microcollybia racemosa (Pers.: Fr.) Lennox  
       = Sclerostilbum septentrionale Povah  
 GYMNOPUS (Quél.) Quél. ex Moug. & Ferry  
    G. acervatus (Fr.) Murrill 10a
       = Collybia acervata (Fr.) P. Kumm.  
       = Marasmius acervatus (Fr.) Pearson & Dennis  
       = Collybia terginoides Svrcek & Kubicka  
    G. alkalivirens (Singer) Halling 17a
       = Collybia alkalivirens Sing.  
       misapplied name = Collybia plexipes Fr. ss. Kauffman in The Agaricaceae of Michigan  
    G. confluens (Pers.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel., et al. 12a
       = Collybia confluens (Pers.: Fr.) P. Kumm.  
       = Marasmius confluens (Pers.: Fr.) Karsten  
       = Collybia ingrata (Schum.: Fr.) Quél.  
    G. dryophilus (Bull.: Fr.) Murrill 19a
       = Collybia dryophila (Bull.: Fr.) P. Kumm.  
       = Marasmius dryophilus (Bull.: Fr.) Karsten  
       = Collybia pinacea Velen.  
    G. dysodes (Halling) Halling 9b
       = Collybia dysodes Halling  
    G. erythropus (Pers.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel. et al. 10b
       = Collybia kirchneri (Thuemen) Halling & Baroni  
       = Collybia erythropus (Pers.: Fr.) P. Kumm.  
       = Marasmius erythropus (Pers.: Fr.) Quél.  
       = Collybia marasmioides (Britz.) Bresinsky & Stangl  
    G. fuscopurpureus (Pers.: Fr.) Antonín, Halling, & Noordel. 17a
    G. fusipes (Bull.: Fr.) S.F. Gray 16b, 28a
       = Collybia fusipes (Bull.: Fr.) Quél.  
       = Collybia crassipes (Schaeff.) Ricken  
       = Collybia lancipes (Fr.) Gillet  
    G. ocior (Pers.) Antonín & Noordel. 28b
    G. peronatus (Bolt.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel., et al. 14a, 18a
       = Collybia peronata (Bolt.: Fr.) P. Kumm.  
       = Marasmius peronatus (Bolt.: Fr.) Fr.  
       = Marasmius urens (Bull.: Fr.) Fr.  
    G. polyphyllus (Peck) Halling 9a
       = Collybia polyphylla (Peck) Sing. ex Halling  
       = Marasmius polyphyllus Peck  
    G. striatipes (Peck) Halling 16a
       = Collybia cylindrospora Kauffman  
       = Marasmius striatipes Peck  
 RHODOCOLLYBIA Singer  
    R. badiialba (Murrill) Lennox 26b, 28b
       = Collybia badiialba (Murrill) Murrill  
       = Gymnopus badiialbus Murrill  
    R. butyracea var. butyracea (Bull.: Fr.) Lennox 20b, 33b
       = Collybia butyracea (Bull.: Fr.) Quél.  
       = Collybia similis Hruby  
    R. butyracea form asema (Fr.: Fr.) Antonín, Noordel., et al. 1a, 20a, 33a
       = Collybia asema (Fr.: Fr.) Gillet  
       = Collybia butyracea var. asema (Fr.: Fr.) Quél.  
       = Collybia butyracea form asema (Fr.: Fr.) Singer  
    R. extuberans (Fr.) Lennox 26b, 28b
       = Collybia extuberans (Fr.) Quél. ss. Lennox  
    R. maculata var. maculata (Alb.& Schw.: Fr.) Singer 13b, 26a, 31b
       = Collybia maculata (Alb.& Schw.: Fr) P. Kumm.  
       = Gymnopus carnosus (Curtis) Murrill  
    R. maculata var. fulva Lennox 13a, 32b
    R. maculata var. immutabilis (A.H. Sm.) Lennox 31b
       = Collybia maculata var. immutabilis A.H. Sm.  
    R. maculata var. nigra Lennox 29a
    R. maculata var. occidentalis (A.H. Sm.) Lennox 27a
       = Collybia maculata var. occidentalis A.H. Sm.  
    R. maculata var. scorzonerea (Fr.) Lennox 23a
       = Collybia maculata var. scorzonerea (Fr.) Gillet  
       = Collybia scorzonerea Fr.  
    R. oregonensis (A.H. Sm.) Lennox 24a
       = Collybia oregonensis A.H. Sm.  
    R. prolixa var. distorta *
    R. subnigra Lennox 30a
    R. subsulcatipes (A.H. Sm.) Lennox 30b
       = Collybia subsulcatipes A.H. Sm.  
    R. unakensis (Murrill) Halling 28b

- END -